RIVALRY GAME RECORDS
(NOTE: This is an incomplete list, compiled from various sources and spliced together. Until complete stats for all games are gathered and corroborated by the statisticians from both schools, it will be lacking. That is not to say these records are in error, but to say they require a double-check. Until then, enjoy this page for what it is.)
For each category, the record holders from each school are listed. Flag High players are listed in green, Coconino in red. In cases of ties, the first to hit the mark is listed. In cases there three or more hold the record, only the first is listed.
INDIVIDUAL GAME RECORDS
RUSHING
Most Rushing Attempts
35 Stan Gill, 1981
32 Ray Smith, 1974
Most Yards Rushing
327 Cooper French, 2022
260 Ceaser Polk, 1991
Most Rushing Touchdowns
6 Ceaser Polk, 1991
5 Cooper French, 2022
PASSING
Most Passing Attempts
39 Eddie Messman, 1986
38 Audie McKee, 1983
Most Completions
21 Audie McKee, 1983
19 Eddie Messman, 1986
Most Yards Passing
354 Audie McKee, 1983
335 Luke Rotter, 2009
Most Touchdowns Passing
4 Audie McKee, 1983
3 Vinny Zanzucchi, 1983 (+ 3 others)
Most Interceptions Thrown
4 Randy McKee, 1980
4 Eddie Messman, 1986
Rick Gwynne, 1988
RECEIVING
Most Receptions
10 Phillip Miller, 1983
10 Dylan Lee, 1999
Most Yards Receiving
230 Phillip Miller, 1983
200 Jake Walton, 2009
Most Touchdowns Receiving
2 Loren Hills, 1978 (+ 5 others)
2 Jesse Tate, 2008 (+2 others)
SCORING
Most Touchdowns
6 Ceaser Polk, 1991 (all rushing)
5 Cooper French, 2022 (all rushing)
Most Extra Points
10 Jose Miguel Villanueva, 2022
5 Jordan Brandel, 2006
Most Field Goals
2 Benny Flores, 1972
2 Adam Davis, 1993
Frankie Gillis, 2003
Most Two-Point Conversions
1 Bryan Seymore, 1973 (+ many others)
1 Tris Gillette, 1976 (+ many others)
Safeties (individual only, not team)
1 Michael Combrink, 2006
Most Points
36 Ceaser Polk, 1991
24 Willard Reaves, 1976
LONGEST PLAYS (in yards)
Longest Rushing Attempt
90 Corrin Johns, 2000 (TD)
64 
Longest Completion
81 Luke Rotter to Jake Walton, 2009 (TD)
76 Brian Henson to Dean Packard, 1988 (TD)
Longest Punt Return
79 Jerry Nichols, 1971 (TD)
70 Adam Shapiro, 1991 (TD)
Longest Kickoff Return
95 Kelvin Gill, 1976 (TD)
95 Corrin Johns, 1999 (TD)
Longest Interception Return
65 Brian White, 2003 (TD)
35 Steve Larson, 1973 (TD)
Longest Field Goal
48 Allen Meacham, 1984
42 Katie Tribble, 1995
MISCELLANEOUS
Most Interceptions
2 Matt Kendall, 1980 (+ 3 others)
2