ALL-RIVALRY TEAM
This is a presentation of the greatest performances in Rivalry history. The players listed here are not necessarily the best in the history of Flagstaff and Coconino High Schools, but rather, they excelled and determined the fate of a specific game.
On the eve of the 50th Rivalry Game, I present this All-Rivalry Team. While many have offered suggestions, these lists were compiled by Flagcoco, It is intended for the further discussion of the Rivalry, and while such lists typically generate controversy, you're welcome to discuss any omissions with me. There have been many noteworthy performances throughout the last half-century; hopefully this list represents the best of the best.
You can read about these players and the games they played in throughout this website.
ALL-RIVALRY TEAM | ||
OFFENSE | ||
FLAGSTAFF EAGLES | Position | COCONINO PANTHERS |
Dylan Lee, Class of '00 | WR | Mark Young, Class of '94 |
Jesse Tate, Class of '10 | WR | Phillip Miller, Class of '84 |
Jake Walton, Class of '10 | WR | Mark Cibik, Class of '83 |
Dylan Mathews, Class of '14 | WR | Eric McCain, Class of '04 |
Brian Zanzucchi, Class of '85 | TE | Scott Cockerel, Class of '86 |
Ben Petrucci, Class of '92 | OL | David Hathaway, Class of '84 |
Jim Passalacqua, Class of '82 | OL | Benny Flores, Class of '74 |
Jimmy Colmenero, Class of '93 | OL | James Shallman, Class of '77 |
Doug Lamphere, Class of '86 | OL | Marvin Hatcher, Class of '75 |
Chuck Potee, Class of '79 | OL | Lawrence Duran, Class of '01 |
Luke Rotter, Class of '10 | QB | Audie McKee, Class of '84 |
Christian Singleton, Class of '17 | QB | Yancy Ayres, Class of '94 |
Ceaser Polk, Class of '93 | TB | Willard Reaves, Class of '77 |
David Winsley, Class of '86 | TB | Ray Smith, Class of '75 |
Pup Gill, Class of '88 | TB | Luke Daulton, Class of '12 |
Tony Cullen, Class of '82 | FB | Bruce Branch, Class of '01 |
DEFENSE | ||
Kaine Kennedy, Class of '12 | DL | Michael Combrink, Class of '07 |
Brian Dierker, Class of '74 | DL | Curtis Bryant, Class of '70 |
David Carder, Class of '91 | DL | Ray Tsingine, Class of '73 |
C.J. Tompkins, Class of '16 | DL | Bubba Ganter, Class of '87 |
Micole Shorty, Class of '82 | LB | Chris Weller, Class of '88 |
Roger Teague, Class of '81 | LB | Jimmy Baca, Class of '86 |
Eric Houser, Class of '86 | LB | Lanny Helberg, Class of '82 |
Chance Halstead, Class of '15 | LB | Austin Gahr, Class of '11 |
Matt Kendall, Class of '81 | DB | Brian White, Class of '04 |
Rick Pearsall, Class of '93 | DB | Andy Wachter, Class of '88 |
Chris Johnson, Class of '07 | DB | Loren Hills, Class of '79 |
Mark Thompson, Class of '09 | DB | Robert Thieme, Class of '71 |
SPECIAL TEAMS | ||
Dawson Gofourth, Class of '87 | K/P | Allen Meachem, Class of '85 |
Kelvin Gill, Class of '78 | RET | Corrin Johns, Class of '01 |